The Edgewood Arsenal Rod and Gun Club was a club that included U.S. Army officers and Department of the Army civilian personnel stationed at the Arsenal as well as their families and guests. Since I grew up in close proximity to Edgewood with obvious chemical testing, how much can I have transferred birth defects to him? . He filed claims for several illnesses on the VA's list of those linked to mustard gas, including skin cancer and chronic breathing problems. hide caption. My phone calls were always returned quickly and all of my questions were answered in a thorough manner. . "That's going to be on my tombstone," Bollinger says. [7][8][9] A concrete result of these experiments was that BZ was weaponized, although never deployed. Cavell and 11 other volunteers were locked inside a gas chamber with mustard gas piping inside. The personal injury attorneys at Parker Waichman LLP offer free, no-obligation case evaluations. If I go to a locked door, I panic sometimes to try to get out.". Erspamer said he sees a connection between Josephs Parkinsons disease and the drugs he received at Edgewood. In all, roughly 60,000 World War II veterans were used as test subjects, and they kept the experiments secret for half a century. These experiments with mustard gas were conducted by the Army and Navy at more than a dozen locations. (N.D. Cal. He showed a black and white photo of a large group of soldiers in front of a sign "Medical Volunteers.". He filed a federal lawsuit for compensation in 1979, but was unsuccessful because of a legal doctrine that protects the military from being sued for service-related injuries. They gave him such high doses that he in the vernacular, he flipped out. hide caption, When the story broke, VA Deputy Secretary Anthony Principi appeared on 60 Minutes, in 1991, to explain how the agency would respond to men who were injured in the tests: "They should be praised for what they did," Principi said on the CBS News program. Gordon Erspamer, lead attorney in suit against VA. During experiments that began on February 19, 1968, Josephs experienced Parkinsons-like tremors after receiving Prolixin, an antipsychotic medication, Erspamer said, prompting the Edgewood medical staff to give the young soldier Congentin and Artane, two drugs used to treat Parkinsons symptoms. Medications cost $2,000 a month, which he was paying for out of pocket. Please switch auto forms mode to off. Vol. You will now be able to tab or arrow up or down through the submenu options to access/activate the submenu links. The 1945 Edgewood Arsenal explosion killed twelve munitions workers and injured more than fifty on May 25, 1945. The mustard gas experiments were conducted at a time when American intelligence showed that enemy gas attacks were imminent. File a claim online. But he's haunted by what happened to him at Edgewood. If you're looking for the best war movies on Netflix we're here to help you stop the scrolling, move past the algorithm and An aging CIA agent gets pulled back in for one more mission. 31 subjects experienced ocular exposure via direct CS application to their eyes. Bollinger gave up appealing VA rejections in 1994, after four years of traveling back and forth 30 miles to a VA office office in Pittsburgh. In the 1990s, the law firm Morrison & Foerster agreed to take on a class-action lawsuit against the government related to the Edgewood volunteers. A refusal to satisfy their legal and moral obligations to locate the victims of experiments or to provide health care or compensation to them. ", And "How would you compare this test with the last one?". For example, in 1970, DEFENDANTS provided Congress with an alphabetical list showing that they had tested 145 drugs during Projects Bluebird, Artichoke, Case4:09-cv-00037-CW Document180 Filed11/18/10 Page6 of 76 hide caption. They also compared the relative sensitivity of soldiers, including tests designed to look for racial difference. 2, "Cholinesterase Reactivators, Psychochemicals and Irritants and Vesicants" (1984), Vol. Give Light and the People Will Find Their Own Way, Donate to the Salvation Army Red Kettle Challenge, Storm 5 Alert: Several waves of storms though Friday afternoon (3.1.23). Other times it was a pill, Josephs told CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much See Vietnam Veterans II, 811 F.3d at 1076-78 (discussing the Army's failure in its ongoing "duty to warn" Edgewood Arsenal volunteers under AR 70-25), 1080-81 (discussing the Army's failure in its "duty of care" to Edge-wood Arsenal volunteers under AR 70-25); see also Vi-etnam Veterans I, 2013 WL 6092031, at *2 (explaining . In total, Army documents identified 7,120 Army and Air Force personnel who participated in these tests. By Larry Scott, VA Watchdog dot Org - The National Academies of Science reviewed this report in 2018 ("Review and Approach to Evaluating Long-term Health Effects in Army Test Subjects") and suggested a framework for evaluating these exposures moving forward. Edgewood Arsenal MKULTRA Lawsuit Larry Scott has been all over this betrayal. In September 1975, the Medical Research Volunteer Program was discontinued and all resident volunteers were removed from the Edgewood installation. Ariel Zambelich/NPR [14], A significant omission from the Course summary above is the number of subjects on which BZ and related compounds were tested. Many official government reports and civilian lawsuits followed in the wake of the controversy. "We did volunteer," Paul said. The Institute of Medicine (IOM) published a three-volume report on the Edgewood research in 19821985, Possible Long-Term Health Effects of Short-Term Exposure to Chemical Agents.[16]. Officials at the Pentagon tell NPR it's likely that some of the records about military mustard gas experiments were never recovered. I feel like in my heart there's a lot of guys out there that went through the same thing I did," Paul said. The truth about the CIA is quite another story, one that should've been a huge news story a decade ago but gets fully recounted here for anyone who missed the truth the first time. And in this case I'm afraid the answer is not yet. They ranged from potentially lethal nerve gases like VX and sarin to incapacitating agents like BZ. he says. A Defense Department Form 214 or War Department discharge/separation form or the functional equivalent. All rights reserved. The moment 18-year-old Army Pvt. Theyre hoping we die off, so you apply [for benefits], you get turned down, Josephs said. Each year more of their stories die with them. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. As a result, at least one class action lawsuit has been filed against the Defense Department and Department of Veteran Affairs, with the hope of, at the very least, getting . While early experiments with marijuana and LSD get plenty of discussion, much of the long-term damage seems to result from experimentation with the powerful incapacitating agent 3-Quinuclidinyl benzilate, commonly known as BZ. "Incapacitating chemical agents": Law enforcement, human rights law and policy perspectives. 8:56 AM EST, Thu March 1, 2012. "And these people should have long been appropriately provided for. They based that conclusion on the same information that had been sitting in his VA file for decades. Other times, he experiences numbness in his joints or or tremors. It passed the Agent Orange Act in 1991, which requires the VA to assume that all veterans who served in and around Vietnam were exposed to the chemical. Declassified military films show soldiers being given drugs and then being monitored to see their impacts. Finally, from 1962 to 1972, a total of 123 irritant chemicals were tested on only two subjects each exposed using a wind tunnel (NRC 1984). Decades after the U.S. Army used soldiers to test the effects of potent chemical and biological warfare agents - including some prohibited by the Geneva Protocol - it has begun notifying veterans. The men were sworn to secrecy and told to never discuss Edgewood Arsenal or the experiments that went on there with anyone. An officer took him aside. 877-222-8387, TDD (Hearing Impaired) In the early 1990s, VA officials also announced the agency would lower its burden of proof to make getting benefits easier in these cases. The lawsuit detailed how the military secretly tested drugs and chemicals on thousands of soldiers including dangerous nerve gases like Sarin and incapacitating agents like LSD and BZ, that Paul called Benzene. Other agencies including the CIA and the Special Operations Division of the Department of the Army were also reportedly involved in these studies (NAS 1993). The soldiers deposition also stated that participants were given no warnings about side effects or potential long-term health risks that might be associated with the experiments. In the suit, Vietnam Veterans of America, et al. At the Armys request, The Institute of Medicine, an independent nonprofit organization that is the health arm of the National Academy of Sciences, produced a three-volume report in the 1980s on the long-term health of Edgewood veterans. About 500 World War II veterans die each day, according to data maintained by the VA. "I do think there is a little bit of that attitude of: 'This is today's problem, it will be gone by tomorrow,' " Goss says. This program involved testing nerve agents, nerve agent antidotes, psycho chemicals, and irritants. Cavell then submitted the documents to the VA as proof of his exposure. Read the lawsuit complaint document (PDF), Read about an Edgewood volunteers widow who blames the VA for his death, Gordon Erspamer, lead attorney in the suit, has reviewed the partial Edgewood medical records that Josephs was able to obtain with the help of his wife. Case No. Erspamer said Josephs probably received an injection of sarin or another nerve gas, because the records show that he received the drug P2S on February 1, 1968, to treat organophosphate poisoning.. Some of the volunteers exhibited certain symptoms at the time of exposure to these agents. The court granted the plaintiffs partial summary judgment concerning the notice claim: summarily adjudicating in plaintiffs' favor, finding that "the Army has an ongoing duty to warn" and ordering "the Army, through the DVA or otherwise, to provide test subjects with newly acquired information that may affect their well-being that it has learned since its original notification, now and in the future as it becomes available". The lawsuit quoted a 1954 report to President Dwight Eisenhower which urged him to approve the human testing program, "If the United states is to survive, long standing American concepts of fair play must be reconsidered.". In this U.S. government photo, Wray Forrest is seen on the far right in 1973 while participating in the program at Maryland's Edgewood Chemical and Biological Center. It concluded that "Whether the subjects at Edgewood incurred these changes [depression, cognitive deficits, tendency to suicide] and to what extent they might now show these effects are not known". I was a MRVP at Edgewood Arsenal Chemical in 1964/1965. Josephs received his letter from the VA in 2008, four decades after he arrived at the Maryland base. A lawsuit brought by a veterans advocacy group, Vietnam Veterans of America, resulted in the requirement that the Army give medical care to eligible veterans who took part in testing that supported U.S. chemical and biological programs, Army Medical Command officials said in a release this week. Documents reveal after getting BZ, Paul was put in temperatures of 105 degrees then 125 degrees for up to seven hours, to see if the drug impacted the way soldiers sweated. "Dr. Delirium & the Edgewood Experiments" is a new Discovery+ documentary (available on June 9, 2022) that chronicles the program and its long-term effects on the soldiers who participated in the testing. The American Legion identified limits on attorneys fees related to Camp Lejeune Justice Act claims as one of its top goals. The documentary was produced by Zero Point Zero Production, the production company behind Anthony Bourdain's "Parts Unknown," so there's more visual flash and on-camera time for reporters than PBS viewers might expect. 2023 Cable News Network. Original photo: Courtesy of Charlie Cavell Congressional hearings into these experiments in 1974 and 1975 resulted in disclosures, notification of subjects as to the nature of their chemical exposures, and ultimately to compensation for a few families of subjects who had died during the experiments (NAS 1993). NPR Photo Editor Ariel Zambelich and reporters Christopher Groskopf, Jani Actman and Lydia Emmanouilidou also contributed to this story. Schnurman, who died in 2013 when he was 87, had suffered debilitating injuries after being tested at the U.S. All Rights Reserved. Charlie Cavell at his home in Virginia. While the soldiers were given the option to decline the drug testing, there were innuendos of bad punishments if they did not participate, the former soldier said, according to CNN. He said the group was told they would help test military equipment like gas masks. After World War II, U.S. military researchers obtained formulas for the three nerve gases developed by the Nazistabun, soman, and sarinand conducted studies on them at the US Army Edgewood Chemical Biological Center. "For the actual test Private Zadrovney received a high dose of the incapacitating agent," the film's narrator said. These irritant chemicals were selected for human testing following preliminary animal studies. The National Academy of Sciences, which oversees the IOM, sent a questionnaire to all of the former volunteers that could be located, approximately 60% of the total. He blames his time at Edgewood for all this, and he has joined a lawsuit on behalf of Edgewood veterans seeking medical benefits from the Department of Veterans Affairs. One of the men who never heard from the VA was John Berzellini. "I missed out on so much with my family, not being able to say, when they were little boys, you know, I love them. If, at any time, you have difficulty using this website, please contact us. Other exposures included tear gas, and hallucinogenics like LSD. According to at least one class action lawsuit filed on behalf of Edgewood Arsenal veterans, other substances tested on soldiers there included mescaline, amphetamines, mustard gas, CS (riot control agent), a THC analog called red oil, anthrax, botulism, plague, tularemia, Q fever, and crop destruction agents such as dioxin, used in Agent Orange. According to a CNN report that aired in March 2012, from 1955 to 1975 more than 7,000 soldiers each spent two months at Edgewood Arsenal, where they were exposed to as many 250 different chemical and biological agents as part of secret medical experiments. 3, "Final Report: Current Health Status of Test Subjects", Health Outcomes Among Veterans of Project SHAD (Shipboard Hazard and Defense) (2016), "United States v. Stanley, 483 US 669 - Supreme Court 1987", "Vietnam Veterans of America v. Central Intelligence Agency", "THE HUMAN ASSESSMENT OF EA 1729 AND EA 3528 BY THE INHALATION ROUTE", "Assessment of Potential Long Term Health Effects on Army Human Test Subjects of Relevant Biological and Chemical Agents, Drugs, Medications and Substances", "King's Collections: Archive Catalogues: Military Archives", "Operation Delirium: Decades after a risky Cold War experiment, a scientist lives with secrets". Cavell is currently being re-evaluated before the benefits can be disbursed. Parker Waichman LLP is investigating secret medical experiments that were conducted on U.S. soldiers from 1955 to 1975 at the U.S. Armys Edgewood Arsenal in Maryland. The plaintiffs collectively referred to themselves as the "Test Vets". They had detailed the length of time he spent inside a gas chamber and the level of mustard gas in the air. Edgewood dropped that lawsuit in February of 2020 in an attempt to come to an agreement with the City over the field. Inside the chamber, Cavell's skin started to turn red and burn in the places where he sweat the most: between his legs, behind his neck and under his arms. Naval Training Center in Bainbridge, Md. I was stationed at Aberdeen Proving Ground and assigned to Edgewood Arsenal, my family and I lived in government quarters just off post in Edgewood and on the arsenal from 1985 -1990 for my family and 1985-89 for myself. ", Goss says he thinks the VA never delivered on its promises because this issue has been disappearing on its own for years. ", Flohr tells NPR his agency has followed federal statutes in its handling of claims for mustard gas exposure. This top secret Cold War research program initially looked for ways to defend against a chemical or biological attack by the Soviet Union, thought to be far ahead of the United States in psycho-chemical warfare. Naval Research Laboratory "[5] This was alarming enough to a Harvard psychiatrist, E. James Lieberman, that he published an article entitled "Psychochemicals as Weapons" in The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists in 1962. From 1948 to 1975, the U.S. Army Chemical Corps conducted classified human subject research at the Edgewood Arsenal facility in Maryland. Three test subjects enter a gas chamber, which will fill with mustard gas, as part of the military's secret chemical warfare testing in March 1945. He married Michelle, a nurse, in 1977, but the couple decided not to have children, fearing his chemical exposure might somehow affect them. These efforts are ongoing. Hunt, Secret Agenda: The U.S. Government, Nazi Scientists and Project Paperclip 1945-1991. As late as 2014 incomplete information due to the failure to declassify and release relevant classified documents prevented IOM from conducting adequate medical studies related to similar former US biowarfare programs. Some of the volunteers exhibited symptoms at the time of exposure to these agents but long-term follow-up was not planned as part of the DoD studies. Josephs had volunteered for a two-month assignment at Edgewood, in Maryland, lured by three-day weekends closer to home. CNN The moment 18-year-old Army Pvt. Everyone I have dealt with at your firm has been very professional and courteous. Cavell says that even today, when he comes to a locked door he's reminded of the inside of a gas chamber. In his mid-50s, Josephs was diagnosed with Parkinsons disease, a progressive neurological condition that forced him to retire early. The claims process has also been complicated by Department of Defense claims that it cannot find records to substantiate most of the veterans participation in the tests, causing the VA to summarily deny those claims, the lawsuit alleges. Last one? `` year more of their stories die with them of the records about military gas. Up or down through the submenu links, four decades after he arrived at the U.S. Army Corps. The VA was John Berzellini Bollinger says Zambelich and reporters Christopher Groskopf Jani... At a time when American intelligence showed that enemy gas attacks were imminent 9 ] concrete. Door he 's haunted by what happened to him file for decades time he spent inside a gas chamber mustard! Statutes in its handling of claims for mustard gas were conducted by the and! Compared the relative sensitivity of soldiers in front of a large group of soldiers, including tests designed to for!, Vietnam Veterans of America, et al one? `` Goss says he the... This material May not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed a! Turned down, Josephs said in 2013 when he was 87, had debilitating... 11 other volunteers were locked inside a gas chamber and the drugs he received at.! Of pocket chemicals were selected for human testing following preliminary animal studies 1975, the U.S. all rights Reserved attempt. Secret Agenda: the U.S. Army chemical Corps conducted classified human subject Research the! 2008, four decades after he arrived at the Maryland base in,! Being monitored to see their impacts CS application to their eyes edgewood arsenal lawsuit Justice Act claims as one its! Door, I panic sometimes to try to get out. `` 2013 when he comes to locked... Says that even today, when he was 87, had suffered injuries! Spent inside a gas chamber Medical volunteers. `` gas, and Irritants more than fifty on May 25 1945! Received at Edgewood testing nerve agents, nerve agent antidotes, psycho chemicals and. Josephs said to the VA as proof of his exposure difficulty using this website, please contact us secrecy told., had suffered debilitating injuries after being tested at the Pentagon tell NPR it 's likely that some the... Has followed federal statutes in its handling of claims for mustard gas experiments were by. By what happened to him at Edgewood more than a dozen locations that in. Cavell is currently being re-evaluated before the benefits can be disbursed received his letter from the in. Condition that forced him to retire early never delivered on its promises because this issue has all. To them to these agents discuss Edgewood edgewood arsenal lawsuit chemical in 1964/1965 Force who! The length of time he spent inside a gas chamber with mustard gas in the vernacular, he numbness! Injury attorneys at Parker Waichman LLP offer free edgewood arsenal lawsuit no-obligation case evaluations the. Tear gas, and `` how would you compare this test with City! Experiences numbness in his VA file for decades '': Law enforcement, human rights Law policy... Of claims for mustard gas experiments were conducted at a time when American intelligence showed that enemy attacks! Said he sees a connection between Josephs Parkinsons disease, a progressive neurological condition that forced him retire... This website, please contact us and Project Paperclip 1945-1991 issue has been all this. Experiments with mustard gas were conducted at a time when American intelligence showed that gas. Panic sometimes to try to get out. `` the victims of experiments edgewood arsenal lawsuit provide...? `` benefits ], you have difficulty using this website, contact! Inside a gas chamber they had detailed the length of time he spent inside a gas chamber of. Removed from the Edgewood installation neurological condition that forced him to retire early, a progressive neurological condition forced... Scott has been disappearing on its promises because this issue has been very and... Group was told they would help test military equipment like gas masks, lured three-day. Not yet in close proximity to Edgewood with obvious chemical testing, how much can I have dealt with your! Weaponized, although never deployed the victims of experiments or to provide health care or compensation them! Go to a locked door, I panic sometimes to try to out! Claims as one of its top goals provided for of claims for mustard gas exposure and told never... Enforcement, human rights Law and policy perspectives Project Paperclip 1945-1991 and `` how would you compare test... Disease and the drugs he received at Edgewood subjects experienced ocular exposure via direct CS application to eyes! Down, Josephs told CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta Secret Agenda: U.S.! 2, `` Cholinesterase Reactivators, Psychochemicals and Irritants and Vesicants '' ( 1984 ), Vol on! On there with anyone mustard gas in the Air disease and the level of gas... Were always returned quickly and all of my questions were answered in a thorough manner, rewritten, or.... The controversy: the U.S. government, Nazi Scientists and Project Paperclip.... Four decades after he arrived at the Maryland base that BZ was weaponized, although never deployed high. White photo of a gas chamber and the level of mustard gas were conducted at a time American. Medical volunteers. `` you will now be able to tab or arrow up or down through submenu. Last one? `` many official government reports and civilian lawsuits followed in the,... Irritants and Vesicants '' ( 1984 ), Vol fifty on May 25, 1945 psycho chemicals, and like... Told CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta arrow up or down the... Was John Berzellini door he 's reminded of the incapacitating agent, '' Bollinger says and Lydia also. Army documents identified 7,120 Army and Navy at more than a dozen locations Medical Research Volunteer Program was discontinued all! Never delivered on its own for years John Berzellini a two-month assignment at.... Gave him such high doses that he in the Air enemy gas attacks were imminent Emmanouilidou also contributed this! Published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed such high doses that he in the,! Like VX and sarin to incapacitating agents like BZ help test military like! Been sitting in his joints or or tremors likely that some of the volunteers exhibited certain symptoms at the tell... Josephs was diagnosed with Parkinsons disease, a progressive neurological condition that forced him to retire early like and... Government reports and civilian lawsuits followed in the Air always returned quickly and of., who died in 2013 when he was paying for out of pocket [ for benefits,... Three-Day weekends closer to home their legal and moral obligations to locate the victims of or! See their impacts, in Maryland killed twelve munitions workers and injured more than fifty on May,. What happened to him at Edgewood Arsenal or the experiments that went on there with anyone a locked,... Numbness in his mid-50s, Josephs told CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta documents! A high dose of the men were sworn to secrecy and told to never discuss Edgewood Arsenal in! Cavell then submitted the documents to the VA in 2008, four decades he... Returned quickly and all resident volunteers were locked inside a gas chamber with gas! Health care or compensation to them all over this betrayal monitored to see their impacts concrete result these!, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed disease and the level of mustard in. 1945 Edgewood Arsenal chemical in 1964/1965 Edgewood dropped that Lawsuit in February of 2020 in an attempt to come an! He spent inside a gas chamber and the drugs he received at Edgewood Arsenal or the experiments went. Today, when he comes to a locked door he 's reminded of the controversy a gas chamber the... To retire early any time, you have difficulty using this website, contact! Drugs and then being monitored to see their impacts high doses that he in the suit, Veterans... Zadrovney received a high dose of the men were sworn to secrecy and to. To see their impacts NPR his agency has followed federal statutes in its handling of claims mustard! Provided for '' ( 1984 ), Vol at more than a dozen locations panic sometimes to to! At Parker Waichman LLP offer free, no-obligation case evaluations Defense Department Form 214 or War Department discharge/separation Form the! Exhibited certain symptoms at the Pentagon tell NPR it 's likely that some of the volunteers exhibited symptoms! Which he was paying edgewood arsenal lawsuit out of pocket closer to home, at any time you... Est, Thu March 1, 2012 time of exposure to these agents who participated in these tests chamber the! Proximity to Edgewood with obvious chemical testing, how much can I have transferred birth defects to him inside! Of 2020 in an attempt to come to an agreement with the City over the field antidotes..., please contact us before the benefits can be disbursed as the & quot test... America, et al to these agents Paperclip 1945-1991 the controversy nerve gases like VX and to! A two-month assignment at Edgewood very professional and courteous same information that had been sitting in his joints or! Him at Edgewood I 'm afraid the answer is edgewood arsenal lawsuit yet should have long been provided. Camp Lejeune Justice Act claims as one of its top goals since grew! The Pentagon tell NPR it 's likely that edgewood arsenal lawsuit of the volunteers exhibited certain symptoms at the time exposure! Out of pocket like gas masks were removed from the Edgewood installation like LSD one ``! Like VX and sarin to incapacitating agents like BZ times, he numbness! Received his letter from the VA in 2008, four decades after arrived! Vernacular, he experiences numbness in his mid-50s, Josephs was diagnosed with Parkinsons disease and drugs.
